Left unfinished at the death of the composer, Gustav Mahler's Tenth Symphony has exerted an enormous fascination on musicologists as well as musicians – a kind of Holy Grail of 20th-century music. Recognized as an intensely personal work, it was initially consigned to respectful oblivion, but over the years, Alma Mahler, the composer’s widow, released more and more of Mahler’s sketches for publication, and gradually it became clear that he had in fact bequeathed an entire five-movement symphony in short score (i.e. written on three or four staves). Of this, nearly half had reached the stage of a draft orchestration, while the rest contained indications of the intended instrumentation. Over the years a number of different completions or performing versions of ‘the Tenth’ have seen the light of day. One of the most often performed and recorded of these is that by Deryck Cooke. Cooke himself insisted that his edition was not a ‘completion’ of the work, but rather a functional presentation of the materials as Mahler left them. Cooke’s performing version of the symphony is the one that Osmo Vanska has chosen to use for the seventh installment in his and the Minnesota Orchestra’s Mahler series, a cycle characterized by an unusual transparency and clarity of sound as well as musical conception.
Please login to post a review
Reviews
Symphonic Music category – Nominee
International Classical Music Awards 2022
Choc de Classica
Yannick Millon - Classica magazine (France) - May 2021
“… Not to be missed!”
Daniel Foley – thewholenote.com – 7 May 2021
Editor’s Choice
“Vänskä's revelatory account lends unique conviction to Mahler’s final thoughts.” *****
Clive Paget – Limelightmagazine.com – 3 April 2021
“There are now a variety of choices for Mahler’s uncompleted final symphony, and, what’s more, in a variety of completions. Many have their virtues, but this new performance by Osmo Vänskä becomes, at a stroke, the definitive take on the piece. What’s more, it puts paid to those arguments which suggest the piece should have been left uncompleted. Not only is Cooke’s completion utterly convincing, the performance is one of the best in this slightly uneven cycle, and the BIS recording quality does full justice to the wide dynamic range…”
Barry Forshaw – cdchoice.co.uk – 11 April 2021
“… I do not believe in a “best” recording in most repertoire works, but, given all its merits, this new Vänskä/Minnesota issue should certainly be considered seriously as a choice in this Symphony.”
Chris Salocks – MusicWeb-International.com – 29 March 2021
Orchestral Choice
Performance **** Recording *****
“…The Minnesota is ideally engaged with the Tenth’s depths.”
David Nice - BBC Music Magazine - April 2021
“…Urgently recommended.”
David A. McConnell – theclassicreview.com - 4 March 2021
“… the Vänskä recording has a lot going for it and those who are collecting his cycle will not be disappointed.”
William Hedley – MusicWeb-International.com – 3 March 2021
Media Downloads
Whenever possible we provide a high resolution CD cover image and a PDF version of the CD booklet for you to download and keep. These are found in your history if purchased and once you have logged in.